Council of God-6
Like the Most High?
In the previous lesson, we saw that Ezekiel 28 presents us with the tragic portrait of the prince of Tyre. The prophet uses the literary strategy of drawing on an ancient account of a divine being in Eden who thought himself heading “the seat of the gods” (Eze. 28:2), the divine council. This being was punished with expulsion from Eden to the underworld. The portrait of this being as a divine guardian cherub, using the imagery of brilliant, shining gems and a serpent, has conceptual links to Gen. 3.
These elements also show up in Isa. 14. We'll consider that passage and then take another look at the serpent representative in Eden.
Isaiah 14
In Isa. 14:4, God tells the prophet to take up a “taunt” (Hebrew: mashal) against the king of Babylon. A mashal is better described as a comparative parable. The question to keep in mind as we proceed is, to whom the king of Babylon being compared?
The beginning of the parable sounds as unfavorable to the king of Babylon as Ezekiel's description of the prince of Tyre is to that ruler. The king of Babylon is called an “oppressor” (esv; v. 4) who relentlessly persecuted the nations (vv. 5-6). The world will finally be at rest when the oppressor is “laid low” (esv; vv. 7-8). In anticipation of the joy of finally being rid of the king of Babylon, the prophet writes:
Isa 14:9 Sheol beneath is stirred up to meet you when you come; it rouses the shades to greet you, all who were leaders of the earth; it raises from their thrones all who were kings of the nations.
Isa 14:10 All of them will answer and say to you: ‘You too have become as weak as we! You have become like us!’
Isa 14:11 Your pomp is brought down to Sheol, the sound of your harps; maggots are laid as a bed beneath you, and worms are your covers.
As in Eze. 28, the figure of Isiah 14 who is the target of its diatribe goes to Sheol, the underworld. The Rephaim are there, here identified again as the dead warrior-kings (“you have become the same as us”). The king of Babylon will be one of these living dead, just like the king of Tyre.
Recall that Ezekiel 28 shifted from the prince of Tyre to a divine figure in Eden. That shift informed us that the writer was using an account of cosmic, divine rebellion to, by comparison, portray the arrogance of the earthly prince. After verse 11, Isaiah 14 shifts to divine context with clear links to Ezekiel 28.
Isaiah 14:15-12 reads:
Isa 14:12 “How you are fallen from heaven, O Day Star, son of Dawn! How you are cut down to the ground, you who laid the nations low!
Isa 14:13 You said in your heart, ‘I will ascend to heaven; above the stars of God I will set my throne on high; I will sit on the mount of assembly in the far reaches of the north;
Isa 14:14 I will ascend above the heights of the clouds; I will make myself like the Most High.’
Isa 14:15 But you are brought down to Sheol, to the far reaches of the pit.
The divine council context is transparent. You've already seen much of the terminology in past lesson about divine gardens and mountains.
The figure to whom the king of Babylon is being compared is a divine being fallen “from heaven” (v.12) He is called the “morning star, son of dawn.” The language takes us back to Job 38:7, where the sons of God were called “morning stars.” But the Hebrew term in Isa. 14:12 are different than those in Job 38:7.
“Morning star, son of dawn” is an English rendering of the Hebrew helel ben-shachar, which literally means “shining one, son of dawn.” When we talk about Job 38:7 in a past lesson, I noted that “morning stars” were the visible bright stars seen on the horizon as the sun rose. Astronomers (ancient and modern) knew another celestial object that behaved the same way-- an object so bright it could still be seen as the sun rose. That object was Venus, and so Venus, though a planet, became known to the ancients as the “bright morning star”
In essence, borrowing the language of Ezekiel 28, Isaiah portrays this particular divine being as hopelessly enamored of his own brilliance. So great was his arrogance that he declared himself above all the “stars of God” (kokebey el), the other members of the divine council (Job 38:7).
That this “shining one” sought superiority over the other members of the divine council is indicated by the phrase “raise … my throne” and his desire to “sit” on “the mountain of assembly.” That this, “mountain of assembly” speaks of the divine council is clear from its location in “Zaphon” (“the north”; tsaphon) and the clouds. The “seat” language is familiar from Eze. 28:2 (the “seat of gods”) Isa. 14 reads like an attempted coup in the divine council. Helel ben-shachar wanted his seat in the divine assembly on the divine mountain to be above all others. He wanted to be “like the Most High” (elyon). But there can be only one of those, God the Father.
It is no surprise that helel ben-shachar, the shining one, meets the same end as the divine throne guardian in Eze. 28. In three place we see his fate. We have gone over two of the verses already. Take note of the bold emphasis:
Isa 14:9 Sheol beneath is stirred up to meet you when you come; it rouses the shades to greet you, all who were leaders of the earth; it raises from their thrones all who were kings of the nations.
Isa 14:12 “How you are fallen from heaven, O Day Star, son of Dawn! How you are cut down to the ground, ['erets]... you who laid the nations low!
Isa 14:15 But you are brought down to Sheol, to the far reaches of the pit.
The punishment of helel is to live in the realm of the dead. Helel ends up in Sheol, the pit (bor); brought down to the earth ('erets) by God, the true Most High.
The table below expands on the one we began in the last lesson. As on divine council connections between that chapter and Isa. 14 and Gen. 3, but will include references from elsewhere when appropriate.
THE DIVINE COUNCIL CONTEXT
Hebrew term English meaning concept important verses
elim, elohim (plural) “gods” council members Gen. 3:5, 22; Psm. 82:1,6 Ezk.28:2
beny elim “sons of God” “ council members Job 38:7; Psm. 29:1; 89:6; Isa. “ 14:13
beny elohim “morning stars” Eze. 28:13 (gems)
kokebey boqer “stars of God” shining appearance
kokebey el “shining one, son of
helel ben-shachar the dawn"
gan “garden” divine abode, council Gen. 2:8-10, 15-16 meeting place Gen. 3:1- 3, 8, 10,
23-24; Eze. 28:13
'ed “(watery)mist” description of the Gen. 2:6, 10-14 (Zion); well watered garden Eze. 47:1-12 of the council (Jerusalem temple, cf.
nahar “river” Zec. 14:8); Eze. 28:2
Yamim “seas, waters”
tsaphon “north” mountain range where Psm. 48:1-2 (Jeru. divine council met temple, cf. Eze. 40:2); Isa. 14:13-14 yarketey tsaphon “heights of the north”
bamot “heights”
har “mount, mountain” mountain range where Exo. 24:15 (Sinai; cf. divine council met Psm. 68:15-17; Deu. 33:1-2; Isa. 14:13;
27:13 (Zion); Eze.
47:1-12 (Jerusalem Temple)
odat "assembly" the divine assembly Psm. 82:1; 89:7; Isa. 14:13; Eze. 28:2
sod “council” Eze. 28:2
mo'ed “meeting”
moshab “seat” (governing)
THE NACHASH OF GENESIS 3
The pivitol character of Gen. 3 is the representative being serpent. The Hebrew word translated sepent is nachash. The word is both plain and elastic.
The most straightforward meaning is the one virtually all translators and interpreters opt for: serpent. When the Hebrew root letters n-ch-sh are a noun, that's the meaning.
But n-ch-sh are also the consonants of a verb. If we chang the vowls to a verb (recall that Hebrew originally had noe vowls), we would have nochesh, which means "the diviner." Divination refers to communication with the supernatural world. A diviner in the ancient world was one who foretold omens or gave out divine information from this being.
The consonants n-ch-sh may also form an alternative noun, nachash, which is at times used descriptively, like an adjective. This term is used in place names outside the Bible and once in the OT. First Chronicles 4:12 refers to "Tehinnah, father of Ir-nachash." The otherwise unknown Tehinnah is reguarded in this verse as the founder of the city (Hebrew: ir) of nachash.
This city has yet to be securely identified by archaeologists. The phrase means "the city of copper/bronze (smiths)." Hebrew words like nechosheth ("bronze"; "copper") are derived from this noun. Ir-nachash was a place known for copper and bronze metallurgy. The option is interesting because copper and bronze are shiny when polished. In fact, the OT uses nechososheth to describe divine beings (Dan. 10:6).
We have words with such elasticity in English, where meaning depends on the part of speech. For example;
(noun): "Running is a good form of exercise."
(Verb): "The engine is running on diesel."
(Adajective): "Running paint is an eye sore."
Sometimes writers, when they use a term, want their readers to think about all possible meanings and nuances. If I ask, "How has your reading been?" the reader is forced to think about all three. Do I mean the latest lesson (noun)? Am I wondering if you got the right glasses (adjective)? Or am I referencing the process (verb)? What I am suggesting is that, since there are immediate clues in the account that the serpent is more than a mere snake, that he may be a divine adversary, the term nachash is a triple entendre. The writer wants his readers to consider all the possible nuances in their interpretive, intellectual experience. All of them carry theological weight.
The serpent (nachash) was an image commonly used in reference to a divine throne guardian. Given the context of Eden, that helps identify the villain as a divine being.The divine adversary depenses divine information, using it to goad Eve. He gives her an oracle (or, an oman!): You won't really die. God knows when you eat you will be like one of the elohim. Lastly, a shining appearence conveys a divine nature. All the means convey something important. They are also consistant with the imagery from Isa. 14 and Eze. 28.
Divine Judgment
I tend to be sympathic toward Eve. She all to often gets cast as stupid and naive. Given the divine council context of her status as God's imager and new member of His family, what the nachash said to her had the ring of validity. Of course God wants us to be like the elohim-- we're all one family. We all represent the creator, don't we? Why would we die?
This doesn't excuse Eve (or Adam). Their disobedience had dire consequences. But while the reason for God's judgment is transparent, the meanings of that judgment beg for some careful thought.
The curse levied at Adam (Gen. 3:17-19) did not supersede God's mandate to subdue the earth and take dominion. But it did make the task harder. The expulsion of humankind from Eden (Gen. 22-25) turned a glorious dominion mission into mundane drudgery. We know that God would take steps to restore His rule, and that descendants of Adam (especially one of them—Gen. 3:15) would be critical of that kingdom. The human yearning for utopia is interesting in this light. We seem to have an inner sense of need to restore something that was lost, but Eden cannot return on purely human terms.
God's judgment on Eve is in some sense entwined with the curse of the nachash. Eve would suffer intensified pain in childbirth (Gen. 3:16: "I will multiply your pain.") There is no indication that, had she borne children before the fall, Eve would hav felt no pain at all. She was human. And it was important that she bear children, since her child bearing would have some relationship to the destiny of the nachash and his deed.
Gen. 3:15 I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and her offspring; he shall bruise your head, and you shall bruise his heel.”
The wording of Gen. 3:15 is veiled. For reasons I will make clear later, I believe prophecies like this that ultimately move in a messianic direction were deliberately cryptic. At the very least the verse tells us that God was not done with humanity yet. The goal of His rule on earth through humanity would not be abandoned. A descendant of Eve would come forth who would someday undo the damage cause by the divine rebel, the nachash. That this descendant is linked to Eve implies that the score will be settled through her bloodline.
This human threat to the nachash is fitting. The seduction to sin meant that Yahweh would have to be true to His word and eliminate humanity. The nachash counted on the justice of God to eliminate his rivals. God was just in this regard. Elimination from Eden did indeed mean death, but not in the sense of immediate annihilation. God would see to it that their lives ended, but not before continuing His plan. Humanity would die, but it also, at some point, produce a descendant who would ultimately restore God's Edenic vision and destroy the nachash.
Adam and Eve ha contingent immortality prior to the fall. They had never-ending life, depending on certain circumstances. The imagery of Eden, home of the life-giver, and its tree of life convey the notion that, so long as Adam and Eve ate from the tree of life, called Eden their home, and didn't do anything that resulted in mortal injury (they were truly human after all), would live. Protected in their perfect environment, they would multiply and carry out their tasks as God's representatives on earth until the job was done.
All that goes by the wayside once they are removed from Eden. God even takes the extra step of preventing them from returning to Edens tree of life (Gen. 3:24). Had they access to it, they would have gone on living, despite what had happened. After the fall, the only way to extend the work of God's human council-family was childbirth. Eve was redeemed through childbearing (1Tim. 2:15). So were the rest of us, in the sense that that is the only way God's original plan remained viable. Where there is childbearing, there can be no human imaging and no kingdom.
But the judgment on Eve also tells us that the nachash would have offspring as well. The rest of the biblical account doesn't consist of humans battling snake people. That's no surprise, since the enemy of humanity wasn't a mere snake. The Bible does, however, describe an ongoing conflict between followers of Yahweh and human and divine beings who follow the spiritual path of the nachash. All who oppose God's kingdom plan are the seed of the nachash.
Consider what happens to the nachash against the back drop of the judgment language found in Ezekiel 28 and Isaiah 14:
Serpent/Shining One Imagery & Punishment
Hebrew term English Meaning concept Important Verses
nachash “serpent” (noun) word play; triple entendre Gen. 3:1-2, 4, 13-14
“to use divination, Image of serpent (divine
give omens” (Verb) “bronze, throne guardian), info.
brazen” (Adj) from divine realm (devina-
tion), shining appearance
assoc. with divinity (brazen)
chawwat “serpent” Gen. 28:12 (with silent m)
helel “shining one, son of the shining appearance assoc. Isa. 14:12
dawn” with divinity Eze. 28:13 (gems)
yarad “brought down” an expulsion from the divine Eze. 28:8, 17
gada' “cut down” presence and former service Isa. 14:11-12, 15
shalak “cast down” role to Yahweh
'erets “earth, ground” underworld, realm of the dead Eze. 28:17
(abstractly): underworld Note: the nachash of Gen. 3 is Isa. 14:9, realm of the dead made to crawl on his belly, 11-12, 15 sheol Sheol; realm of the dead put on the ground, under the feet
of animals (Gen. 3:14)
rephaim “Rephaim; the “shades”; underworld occupants Eze. 28:17
the dead in the underworld Isa. 14:9
melakim “kings” (fallen enemies)
The nachash was cursed to crawl on his belly, imagery that conveyed bring cast down (Eze. 28:8, 17; Isa. 14:11-12,15) to the ground. In Ezekiel 28 and Isaiah 14, we saw the villain cast down to the 'erets, a term that refers literally to the dirt and metaphorically to the underworld (Eze. 28:17; Isa. 14:9, 11-12, 15). The curse also had him “eating dirt,” clearly a metaphorical reference, since snakes don't actually eat dirt as food for nutrition. It isn't part of the “natural snake diet.” The point being made by the curse is that the nachash, who wanted to be “most high,” will be, “most low” instead—cast away from God and the council to earth, and even under the earth. In the underworld, the nachash is even lower than the beasts of the field. He is hidden from view and from life in God's world. His domain is death. After the fall, though humankind was estranged from God and no longer immortal, the plan of God was not extinguished. Gen. 3 tells us why we die, why we need redemption and salvation, and why we cannot save ourselves. It also tells us that God's plan has only been delayed—not defeated—and that the human account will be both tragic struggle and a miraculous, providential saga.
But the situation is going to get worse before it gets better.