Council of God-4
Peril and Providence
An Jewish reader would have thought differently about the questions in the last lesson than most believers would today.
God's Gift
We might wonder why God doesn't do away with evil and suffering on earth. The answer sounds paradoxical: He can't – because that would require elimination of all His imagers. But He will at the last day. For evil to be eliminated, earth and humanity as we know it would have to end. God has a chronology, a plan, for this ultimate development. It could be no other way, given His decision to create time-bound humans as the vehicles for His rule. But in the meantime, we experience the positive wonders of life as well. Though God knew the risk of Eden, He deemed the existence of humankind preferable to our eternal absence.
Despite the risk of evil, free will is a wonderful gift. God's decision was a loving one. Understanding that requires only a consideration of the two alternatives: (1) not having life at all, and (2) being a mindless robot, capable only of obeying commands and responding to programming.
If our decisions were all coerced, how authentic would those “decisions” actually be? If love is coerced or programmed, is it really love? Is any such decision really a genuine decision at all? It isn't.
We all know the difference between freedom and coercion. Free will is a gift, despite the risk.
Knowing Good and Evil
Several phrases in Genesis 3:5, 22 that have puzzled interpreters become more understandable in light of what we've been discussing. In Gen. 3:5 the serpent (Hebrew: nachash) says to Eve: “For God (elohim) knows on the day you both eat from it, then your eyes will be opened and you both will be like gods (elohim), knowing good and evil.” This verse is like Psm. 82:1. The word elohim occurs two times in the same verse. The first instance is singular because of grammar (the verb “knows” is singular in form). While most English translations render the second instance as “God,” it should be plural because of the context supplied by Gen. 3:22. That verse reads: “And Yahweh God said, “Look – the man has become as one of us, to know good and evil.” The phrase “one of us” informs us that, as in Gen. 1:26, God is speaking to His council members – the elohim. This tells us clearly that the second instance of elohim in Gen. 3:5 should be plural.
This fits well with Psm. 8:5, where the Psalmist notes that humankind was created “a little lower than the elohim.” We aren't a “little” lower than God – we're light years lower. In Hebrews 2:7 the writer quotes Psm. 8:5 from the Septuagint. That translation reads the plural “angels” for elohim , a clear plural.
In Gen. 3:5 Eve is being told that if she violates God's command, she and Adam will become elohim, knowing good and evil. Notice that the phrase is “knowing good and evil,” not will be capable of good and evil. As free-will beings, Adam and Eve were already capable of disobedience. Like God's holy ones in council, they were imperfect. But Adam and Eve had not yet experienced evil – either by their own commission or as bystanders,
The “knowing good and evil” phrase with the same Hebrew vocabulary occurs elsewhere. Deu. 1:39 says:
And as for your little ones, who you said would become a prey, and your children, who today have no knowledge of good or evil, they shall go in there. And to them I will give it, and they shall possess it.
The little children referred to here are the generation of Israelites that would arise after the original generation that had escaped from Egypt at the exodus. That first generation had been sentenced by God to wonder in the desert for forty years until they died off for their refusal to enter the promised land in conquest (Num. 14). The new generation did not know good or evil and would be allowed entrance into the land.
The meaning is clearly that the second generation was nor held morally accountable for the sins of their parents. Though as children they were under the authority of their parents, they had no decision-making authority in the matter and thus were not willing participants. Therefore they were not considered liable. They were innocent.
The same perspective makes sense in Gen. 3. Prior to knowing good and evil, Adam and Eve were innocent. They had never made a willing, conscious decision to disobey God. They had never seen an act of disobedience, either. When they fell, that changed. They did indeed know good and evil, just as God and the rest of His heavenly council members – including the nachash (“serpent”).
Evil and Foreknowledge
Acknowledging God's foreknowledge and also the genuine free will of humankind, especially with the respect to the fall, raises obvious questions: Was the fall predestined? If so, how was the disobedience of Adam and Eve free? How are they truly responsible?
Since we aren't told much in Genesis about how human freedom works in relation to divine attributes life foreknowledge, predestination, and omniscience, we need to look elsewhere in Scripture for some clarification. Let's look at 1 Sam. 23:1-13.
In this account, David appeals to the omniscience God to tell him about the future. In the first instance (23:1-5), David asks God whether he should go to the city of Keilah and whether he'll successfully defeat the Philistines there. God answers in the affirmative in both cases. David goes to Keilah and indeed defeats the Philistines. In the second section (23:6-13), David asks the Lord two questions: (1) will his nemesis Saul come to Keilah and threaten the city on account of David's presence? And (2) will the people of Keilah turn him over to Saul to avoid Saul's wrath? Again, God answers both questions affirmatively: “He will come down,” and “They will deliver you.”
Neither of these events that God foresaw ever actually happened. Once David hears God's answers, he and his men leave the city. When Saul discovers this fact (vs. 13), he abandons his trip to Keilah. Saul never made it to the city. The men of Keilah never turned David over to Saul.
Why is this significant? This passage clearly establishes that divine foreknowledge does not necessitate divine predestination. We see God foreknew what Saul would do what the people of Keilah would do given a set of circumstances. In other words, God foreknew a possibility – but this foreknowledge did not mandate that the possibility was actually predestined to happen. The events neer happened, so by definition they could not have been predestined. Ans yet the omniscient God did foresee them. Predestination and foreknowledge are separable.
The theological point can be put this way:
That which never happens can be foreknown by God, but it is not predestined, since it never happened.
But what about things that do happen? They can obviously be foreknown, but were they predestined?
Since we have seen above that foreknowledge in itself does not necessitate predestination, all that foreknowledge truly guarrantees is that something is foreknown.
Implications
A Jewish reader would have embraced this parcing of foreknowledge, predestination, sovereignty, and free will. He would not have been encombered by a theological tradition. They would have understoodthat this is the way God Himself has decided His rule over human affairs will work. These are Yahweh's decisions, and we accept them.
This has significant implications for not only the fall, but the presence of evil in our world in general. God is not evil. There is no biblical reason to argue that God predestined the fall, though He foreknew it. There is no biblical reason to assert that God predestined all the evil events throughout human history simply because He foreknew them.
All this means that what we choose to do is an important part of how things will turn out. What we do matters. God has decreed the ends to which all things will come. As believers, we are prompted by His Spirit to be the good means to those decreed ends.
But the Spirit is not the only influence. The experiences of our lives involve other imagers, both good and evil, including divine imagers we cannot see. Loyal members of God's "congeregation" (council), sent to minister to us (Heb.1:14), have embraced God's Edenic vision – we are brothers and sisters (Heb. 2:10-18).
Other divine beings would oppose God's plan. The original dissident takes center stage as we will see.