Council of God-5
Trouble in Paradise
The account of the Fall of Humanity in Gen. 3 seems straightforward, perhaps because we've heard it told so many times. The truth is that the passage presents a lot of interpretive questions. We've devoted some time to a couple of them in previous lessons. Now it is time to examine the main character, the serpent. Once again, there's a lot more than meets the eye here.
One of the things that always bothered me about the account was why Eve wasn't afraid witless when the serpent spoke to her. There's no indication that she thought the incident unusual.
The truth is that an ancient reader would not have expected Eve to be frightened. Given the context-- she was in Eden, the realm of Yahweh and His elohim council – it would have been clear that she was conversing with a divine being. As we've seen in earlier lessons, that Eve was on divine turf.
Genesis 3 in Context
In ancient Near East literature of the OT world, animal speech is not uncommon. The context for such speaking is that of magic, which of course is tied to the world of the gods, or direct divine intervention. No Egyptian, for example, would have presumed that the animals they experienced in their normal lives could talk. But when the gods or magical forces were in view, that was a different story.
Consequently, the point of Gen. 3 is not to inform us about ancient zoology or a time when animals could talk. We're not in the realm of science by design. Genesis simple but profound ideas to Israelite readers: The world you experience was created by an all-powerful God; human beings are His created representatives; Eden was His abode; He as accompanied by a supernatural host; one member of that divine entourage was not pleased by God's decisions to create humanity and give them dominion. All that leads to how humanity got into the mess it's in.
In some respects, we know that the Genesis “serpent” wasn't really a member of the animal kingdom. We have other passages to help us grasp that point, particularly in the NT. We understand that, even though NT writers refer to the serpent back in Eden, they are really referring to a supernatural entity – not a mere member of the animal kingdom (2Cor. 11:3; Th. 3:5; Rev. 12:9).
This is how we need to think about the account of Genesis 3. An Israelite would have known that the episode described interference in the human drama by a divine being. A malcontent from within Yahweh's council. The vocabulary used by the writer reveals several things about the divine enemy that has emerged from the divine council. If we're thinking only in terms of a snake, we'll miss the messaging.
My task in this lesson and the next is to help you think beyond the literalness of the serpent language. If it is true that the enemy in the Garden was a supernatural being, then he was not a snake.
But it's also true that the account is told as it is for a reason. As odd as it sounds, the vocabulary and the imagery are designed to alert readers to the presence of a divine being, not a literal snake. Making that case will involve comparing Genesis 3 to other OT passages. But to see that those passages are indeed conceptually linked to Genesis 3, we need to review some things we have learned.
Eden was the divine abode and, therefore, the place where Yahweh held council meetings. Here are some of the terms and verses associated with Eden we briefly noted in an earlier lesson. I've added the Hebrew words behind the English.
Hebrew Term English Meaning concept important verses elim, elohim (plural) “gods” council mbrs. Gen. 3:5, 22
gan “garden” divine abode, Gen. 2:8-10,15-16 Gen. 3:1- 3, 8, 10, 23-24 'ed "(watery) mist" discript. of Gen. 2:6, 10-14
well- watered Eze. 28:2
nahar "river" garden of council
YAMIM "SEAS, WATERS"
HAR "MOUNT, MOUNTAIN" MOUNTAIN RANGE WHERE Eze. 28:13
divine council met
moshab elohim "seat of the god's" (place the divine assembly Eze. 28:2
of governing authority
You can see quickly that, other that Gen. 2-3, the other source of verse citations is Ezekiel 28.That's one of the lessons conceptually linked to Gen. 3. Its connection is explicit. Eze. 28:13-14 refers to “Eden, the garden of God … God's holy mountain”
Ezekiel 28
Ezekiel 28 is not specifically about the fall of mankind. It's also not a commentary on Gen. 3. The chapter begins with God chastising the prince of Tyre (Eze. 28:1-8). God accuses this prince of extraordinary arrogance. In verse 2 the prince considers himself a god (el), who sits in the seat of the gods (moshab elohim), a term associated with the divine council.
The choice of el for who the prince considers himself to be is interesting. It also appears in verse 9, where it is in parallel elohim. The word el is another word that means “god” in Hebrew and other Semitic languages. The people of Ugarit called their high god El – they used the term as a proper name. So did the people of Tyre, which was a Phoenician city. The Phoenician religion had a divine council led by El, who was also called elyon (“Most High”) in Phoenician texts and considered the creator of the earth.
To the ancient reader familiar with El, the notion that the prince of Tyre would think himself fit to rule in El's place (or even to be a more generic deity-participant in the divine council) would be ludicrous. For biblical writers, the idea was also offensive. For them Yahweh was Most High – the true king of all gods and creator of heaven and earth. This is why the biblical writers refer to Yahweh as el-elyon (“God Most High”; Gen. 14:20, 22). The point of assigning el and elyon to Yahweh was not how to endorse how Phoenicians and residents of Ugarit thought about their gods, but assert Yahweh”s superiority. He was incomparable among spiritual beings; the others were pretenders. Consequently, the biblical writers would have viewed the human arrogance of the prince of Tyre as an affront to the God of Israel.
God proceeds to acknowledge the great intelligence of this prince, but reminds him that he is not god, and certainly not the Most High (Eze. 28:2-6). This sort of arrogance must be punished. Judgment will come. God asks sarcastically (v.9), “Will you indeed still say 'I am a god!' before the face of your killers?”
In verse 10 God adds a strange detail: “You will die the death of the uncircumcised by the hand of strangers.” Since the prince of Tyre is an uncircumcised Gentile anyway, the phrasing seems to lack coherence. If we read a little further in Ezekiel, the point would be clear to an ancient reader. The underworld realm of the dead, Sheol, is described by Ezekiel as the place where the uncircumcised warrior-king enemies of Israel finds themselves (Eze. 32:21, 24-30, 32; Isa. 14:9). This is the place of the Rephaim dead, quasi-supernatural beings we'll encounter later.
It is at this point God has the prophet raise a lament over the prince of Tyre, the brilliant prince whose arrogance led to his fall, not only to the earth but under the earth. God, through the prophet, begins:
Eze. 28:12 “Son of man, raise a lamentation over the king of Tyre, and say to him, Thus says the Lord GOD: “You were the signet of perfection, full of wisdom and perfect in beauty.
Eze. 28:13 You were in Eden, the garden of God; every precious stone was your covering, sardius, topaz, and diamond, beryl, onyx, and jasper, sapphire, emerald, and carbuncle; and crafted in gold were your settings and your engravings. On the day that you were created they were prepared.
This verse raises questions. The prince of Tyre wasn't in Eden – he was in Tyre. We see now that, although Ezekiel 28 is about the prince of Tyre, in describing this prince's arrogance, downfall, and original state, the prophet utilizes an older tail of the downfall in Eden.
The Hubris of Adam
Many scholars argue that Edenic figure in view is Adam. This view depends on rejecting the traditional Hebrew text of the passage. If one prefers the Septuagint here. Then God is speaking to an individual who is “with the anointed cherub” – as opposed to speaking directly to the anointed cherub. The more coherent alternative is that the cherub is the serpent – more pointedly, a divine being who has forgotten his place in the pecking order.
But where do we see a serpent in Ezekiel 28? Let's look first at what is clear before addressing the question.
This “prince” was in Eden, the garden of God (v. 13) He is beautiful – words like shining or radiant are what come to mind when reading about the panoply of gems that were his “adornment” (vv.12b-13).
Some have taken this language to refer to a literal jewel-encrusted garment worn by the human prince. They in turn argue that the prince of Eden was Adam. They also note that many of the jewels listed here correspond to the jewels on the breastplate of the Israel high priest (Exo. 28:17-20; 39:10-13). The picture, they say, is Adam as priest-king of Eden. Since Jesus was the second Adam and a priest-king, the analogy fits. The backdrop to the prince of Tyre's arrogance is the rebellious Adam, not the serpent.
This sounds reasonable until you start looking at how “Adam” is characterized in the verses that follow.
Eze. 28:14 You were an anointed guardian cherub. I placed you; you were on the holy mountain of God; in the midst of the stones of fire you walked.
Eze. 28:15 You were blameless in your ways from the day you were created, till unrighteousness was found in you.
Eze. 28:16 In the abundance of your trade you were filled with violence in your midst, and you sinned; so I cast you as a profane thing from the mountain of God, and I destroyed you, O guardian cherub, from the midst of the stones of fire.
Eze. 28:17 Your heart was proud because of your beauty; you corrupted your wisdom for the sake of your splendor. I cast you to the ground; I exposed you before kings, to feast their eyes on you.
Was Adam with an “anointed guardian cherub”? Where do we read in Genesis 3 that Adam was filled with violence, or that his sin was propelled by the fact that he was egotistically enamored of his own beauty and splendor? When was Adam cast to the ground to be exposed before kings (v. 17)?
All of the phrases alluded to in the questions above are important. Dealing with them will take the rest this lesson and the next. The key question that frames any discussion of them is this: Is Ezekiel drawing on a tail about the rebellion of a divine being against God, or about Adams rebellion against God? I believe the former is more coherent, a decision that link's what is going on here back to the only divine rebel in Gen. 3 – the divine being represented by the serpent. In what remains of this lesson. I'll begin to explain my reasoning, and then continue that exploration in the next lesson.
Another Approach
Ezekiel 28:12b addresses the prince of Tyre this way: “You were a perfect model of an example.” This line is one of the more troublesome in the book for translation. Some scholars go as far as to list it among the more problematic in the entire OT. The Hebrew word behind “perfect model” or “signet ring” (ch-w-t-m) is the crux of the problem. The word is not a noun, but a participle that literally means “the sealer.” A translation of “signet ring” takes the term to denote some object, but the term is addressed as a person (“You”). The fact that is “sealer” is described as being “full of wisdom” and “perfect in beauty” also make it clear that an object is not in view, but some intelligent person or entity.
The question of course is just how this entity should be identified. Ultimately, the answer to this question derives from the answer to the previous question of whether Ezekiel is drawing on a account about a divine rebel or a human one. That question is the focus of the next lesson. But there are certain observations that can be made here that will help frame that discussion.
Let's reconsider the gemstones that describes the appearance of the “sealer” in Ezekiel 28:13. As I mentioned earlier, proponents of the view that Ezekiel is drawing on Adam's rebellion for his analogous portrayal of the prince of Tyre want to argue that the gemstones point to a human priest-king. But the “adornment” can quite easily be communicating something else – divinity. All of the gems have one thing in common – they shine or sparkle. Luminescence is a characteristic of divine beings or divine presence across the ancient Near Eastern world and the OT (e.g., Eze. 1:4-7, 27-28[cf. Eze. 10:19-20]; Dan. 10:6; Rev. 1:15). This description of the divine cherub in Eden is designed to convey divinity – a shining presence.
There are more details. The anointed cherub ultimately gets cast out of Eden, out from "the midst of the stones of fire." We already know from other data that Eden is the place of the council. The "stones of fire" is another cluein that direction. This phrase is associated in other Jewish texts (1Enoch 18;6-11; 24-25) with the supernatural, mountainous dwelling of God and the divine council.
It may be objected here that Eden was the dwelling place of God and so the "stones of fire" do not only point to the divine beings of Yahweh's council. That much is true, but there's more to the phrase than a dwelling place. Other scholars have also drawn attention to the ancient Near Eastern propensity to describe divine beings as stars. Job 38:7 refers to the sons of God as "stars," and Isaiah 14:12-13 refers to a being fallen from heaven as the "Day star, son of the dawn" (esv) who wanted to ascend above the "stars of God" in the divine realm. The "ground" to which this haughty divine being is cast and where he is disgraced is also of interest. The Hebrew word translated "ground" is 'erets. It is a common term for the earth under our feet. But it is also a word that is used to refer to the underworld, the realm of the dead (e.g., Jonah 2:6), where ancient warrior-kings await their comrades in death (Eze. 32:21, 24-30, 32; Isa. 14:9). Adam, of course, was already on earth, so he couldn't be sentenced there. And he didn't wind up in the underworld. Yet this is the sort of language we eould expect if the point was the expulsion of a heavenly being from the divine council.
Lastly, some scholars have suggested that the problematic term "sealer" (Hebrew ch-w-t-m) might be a criptic reference to the serpent figure of Gen. 3. If their suggestion is correct, the point of confusion becomes a cleaver signal that Adam is not in view.
There is a rear phenomenon in ancient semitic languages where the final letter m is silent (the "enclitic mem"). If the m is made silent in (in effect, removed from) our confusing word, the word becomes ch-w-t, which means "serpent" in Phoenician and other semitic languages. That noun in its lemma form is ch-w-h.
Though the case for this reading cannot be made conclusively, its message would be to read Eze. 28:11-19 in light of Gen. 3 and its serpent. It procuces a play on words that takes us back to the scene of the fall in Eden. Since we know that we are not dealing with a mere animal in Gen. 3, but rather a divine beingthat is cast as creaturely, the discription that this figure in the garden was an "anointed guardian cherub" makes sense. A cherub was a divine throne guardian in tha ancient Far Eastern worldview. Ancient Far Eastern art and engravings have many examples of such throne guardians as animals, including serpents. There is little coherence ito viewing the guarding cherub in Eze. 28 as the human Adam.
Let's summerize where this leaves us. Eze. 28 browbeats the prince of Tyre using an ancient tail of divine arrogance in Eden, where a member of Yahweh's council thought himself on par with the Most High. This divine throne guardian was expelled from Eden to the "ground" or underworld.
These elements show up in another passage: Isa. 14. We'll consider in the next lesson what Isaiah says next and then take a fresh look at what went on in Eden.