The Bad Seed
New Testament Writers
In the last lesson we learned that the NT writers par took of the intellectual climate of their own Jewish community, a community that flourished in the period between the OT and NT. It might seem unnecessary to mention this, given the enthusiasm many Bible readers have today for tapping into the Jewish mind to understand the words of Jesus and the Apostles. When it comes to Genesis 6:1-4, though, that enthusiasm often sours, since the result doesn't support the most comfortable modern Christian interpretation.
The truth is that the writers of the NT knew nothing of the Sethite view, no any view that makes the sons of God in Gen. 6:1-4 humans. Our goal in this lesson is to revisit the passage and dig deeper. When we take it on its own terms, we can determine its character and meaning.
The Ancient Near Eastern Context
Tat Genesis 1-11 has many connections to Mesopotamian literature is not disputed by scholars, evangelical or otherwise. The account of creation, the genealogies before the flood, the flood itself, and the tower of Babel incident all have secure connections to Mesopotamian that is much older than the OT.
Genesis 6: 1-4 , too, has deep Mesopotamia roots that, until very recently, have not been fully recognized or appreciated. Jewish literature line 1 Enoch that retold the account shows a keen awareness of that Mesopotamia context. This awareness shows us that Jewish thinkers of the Second Temple period understood, correctly, that the account involved divine beings and giant offspring. That understanding is essential to grasping what the biblical writers were trying to communicate.
Gen. 6:1-4 is a polemic; it is a literary and theological effort to undermine the credibility of Mesopotamian gods and other aspects of that culture's worldview. Biblical writers do this frequently. The strategy often involves borrowing lines and motifs from the literature of the target civilization to articulate correct theology about Yahweh and to show contempt for other gods.
Genesis 6:1-4 is a study in this technique.
Mesopotamia had several versions of the account of a catastrophic flood, complete with a large boat that saves animals and humans. They include mention of a group of sages (the apkallus), possessors of great knowledge, in the period before the flood. These apkallus were divine beings. Many apkallus were considered evil; those apkallus are integral to Mesopotamian demonology. After the flood, offspring of the apkallus were said to be human in descent (i.e., having a human parent) and “two-thirds apkallu. In other words, the apkallus mated with human women and produced quasi-divine offspring.
The parallels to Gen. 6:1-4 are noteworthy, since it precisely matches the description of the Mesopotamian hero Gilgamesh. Recent critical work on the cuneiform tablets of the epic of Gilgamesh has revealed that Gilgamesh was considered a giant who retained knowledge from before the flood.
Other connections: In the Mesopotamian flood account found in a text now known as the Erra Epic, the Babylonian high god Marduk punishes the evil apkallus with banishment to the subterranean waters deep inside the earth, which were known as Apsu. The Apsu was also considered part of the underworld. Marduk commanded that they never come up again. The parallels are clear and unmistakable . The banishment of these sinister divine beings to beneath the earth is significant. In the last lesson, I noted that this element of the account, found in 2 Peter and Jude, is not found in the OT. The presence of this item in books like 1 Enoch and, subsequently, in the NT, is a clear indication that Jewish writers between the testaments were aware of the Mesopotamian context of Gen. 6:1-4.
There are two other features to highlight in our discussion before we discuss what it all means.
The Sons Of God:
Watchers, Sons of Heaven, Holy Ones
The divine transgression before the flood is retold in several Jewish texts from the intertestamental period. At least one has the divine offenders coming to earth to “fix” the mess that was humankind—to provide direction and leadership through their knowledge. They were trying to help, but once they assumed flesh, they failed to resist its urges. The more common version of events, one wit a more sinister flavor, is found in 1 Enoch 6-11. This is the reading that informed Peter and Jude. The account begins very much like Genesis 6:
And when the sons of men had multiplied, in those days, beautiful and comely daughters were born to them. And they said to one another, “Come, let us choose for ourselves wives from the daughters of men, and let us beget for ourselves children”
The account has the watchers descending to Mount Hermon, a site that will factor into the biblical epic in unexpected ways. Watcher, the English translation of Aramaic 'ir, is not new to us. In an earlier lesson about how God and His council participated together in decision making, we looked at part of Daniel 4, one of the sections of Daniel written in Aramaic, not Hebrew. Daniel 4 is the only biblical passage to specifically use the term watcher to describe the divine “holy ones” of Yahweh's council. The geographical context of Daniel is of course Babylonian (Dan. 1:1-7), which is Mesopotamia.
The offspring of the watchers (sons of God) in 1Enoch were giants (1Enoch 7). Some fragments of 1 Enoch among the Dead Sea Scrolls give names for some of the giants. Other texts that retell the account and are thus related to 1 Enoch do the same. The most startling of these is known today by scholars as The Book of Giants. It exists only in fragments, but names of several giants, offspring of the watchers, have survived. One of the names is Gilgamesh, the main character of the Mesopotamian Epic of Gilgamesh.
Figurines of apkallus, the Mesopotamian counterparts to the sons of God, are known through the work of Mesopotamian archaeologists. They were buried in rows of boxes as parts of foundation walls for Mesopotamian buildings to ward off evil powers. These boxes were referred to by Mesopotamians as mats-tsaery, which means “watchers”. The connection is explicit and direct.
The Nephilim
One of the greatest debates over Genesis 6:1-4 is the meaning of the word nephilim. We've seen from the Mesopotamian context that the apkallus were divine, mated with human women, and produced giant offspring. We've also seen that Jewish thinkers in the Second Temple period viewed the offspring of Gen. 6:1-4 in the same way—giants. Any analysis of the term nephilim must account for, not ignore or violate, these contexts.
Interpretation of the term nephilim must also account for another Jewish phenomenon between the testaments—translation of the OT into Greek. I reference here the Septuagint. The word nephilim occurs twice in the Hebrew Bible (Gen. 6:4; Num. 13:33). In both cases the Septuagint translated the term with gigas (“giant”).
Give the backdrop we've covered, it would seem obvious that nephilim ought to be understood as “giants.” But many commentators resist the rendering, arguing that it should be read as “fallen ones” or “those who fall upon” (a battle expression). These options are based on the idea that the word derives from the Hebrew verb n- p- l (naphal, “to fall”). More importantly, those who argue that nephilim should be translated with one of these expressions rather than “giants” do so to avoid the quasi-divine nature of the Nephilim. That in turn makes it easier for them to argue that the sons of God were human.
In reality, it doesn't matter whether “fallen ones” is the translation. In both thought, their fathers are divine and the nephilim (however translated) are still described as giants. Consequently, insisting that the name mean “fallen” produces no argument to counter a supernatural interpretation.
Despite the uselessness of the argument, I'm not inclined to concede the point. I don't think nephilim means “fallen ones.” Jewish writers and translators habitually think “giants” when they use or translate the term. I think there is a reason for that.
Explaining the biblical view of what the term means involves Hebrew morphology, the way words are spelled or formed in Hebrew. Since the discussion gets technical very quickly, we will see those details latter, at least for the most part. But since I don't like to leave questions unanswered, we need to devote some attention to it here.
The spelling of the word nephilim provides a clue to what root word the term is derived from. Nephilim is spelled two different ways in the Hebrew Bible: nephilim and nephiylim. The difference between them is the “y” in the second spelling. Hebrew originally had no vowels. All words were written with consonants only. As time went on, Hebrew scribes started to use some of the consonants to mark long vowel sounds. English does this with the “y” consonant –sometimes it's a vowel. Hebrew does that with its “y” letter, too (the yod).
The takeaway is the second spelling (nephiylim) tells us that the root behind the term had a long-i (y) in it before the plural ending (-im) was added. That in turn helps us determine that the word does not mean “those who fall.” If that were the case, the word would have been spelled nophelim. A translation of “fallen” from the verb naphal, we'd expect a spelling of nephulim for “fallen.”
However, there's another possible defense for the meaning 'fallen.” Instead of coming from the verb naphal, the word might come from a noun that has a long-i vowel in the second syllable. This kind of noun is called a qatiyl noun. Although there is no such noun as naphiyl in the Hebrew Bible, the hypothetical plural form would be nephiylim, which is the long spelling we see in Num. 13:33.
The option solves the spelling problem, but it fails to explain everything else: the Mesopotamian context, the Second Temple Jewish recognition of that context, the connection of the term to Anakim giants (Num. 13:33; Deu. 2-3), and the fact that the Septuagint translators interpreted the word as “giants.”
So where does the spelling nephiylim come from? Is there an answer that would simultaneously explain why the translators were consistently thinking “giants.”?
There is indeed.
Recall that the OT tells us that Jewish intellectuals were taken to Babylon. During those seventy years, the Jews learned to speak Aramaic. They later brought it back to Judah. This is how Aramaic became the primary language in Judea by the time of Jesus.
The point of Gen. 6:1-4 was to express contempt for the divine Mesopotamian apkallus and their giant offspring. Biblical writers had an easy choice of vocabulary for divine beings: sons of God. Their readers would know that the phrase pointed to divine beings, and other passages in the Torah (Deu. 32:17) labeled other divine beings as demons (shedim). But these writers needed a good word to villainize the giant offspring. “Fallen ones” doesn't relate giantism, so that didn't help them make the point. A view is that, to solve this messaging problem, the Jewish scribes adopted an Aramaic noun: naphiyla—which means “giant.” When you import that word and pluralize it for Hebrew. You get nephiylim, just what we see in Num.13:33. This is the only explanation to the meaning of the word that accounts for all the contexts and all the details.
The Strategy Of Genesis 6
But what does it all mean? Why is Gen. 6:1-4 in the Bible? What was its theological message? We've already noted that the goal was polemic—a dismissal of Mesopotamian religion. But that's a little vague. Let's explore it.
Because the content of Genesis 1-11 has so many deep, specific touch-points with Mesopotamian literary works, many scholars believe that these works were either written during the exile in Babylon or were edited at that time. The scribes wanted to make it clear that certain religious ideas about the gods and the world were misguided or false.
Think about the setting. The Jews, followers of Yahweh, were in Babylon, deported against their will by the greatest empire in their own world. Though captives, prophets like Ezekiel (and Jeremiah before him) had told the people that their situation was temporary—that the God of Israel remained the real sovereign. He was fully in control and was the true God. They would be set free and Babylon would crumble. For Jewish scribes, their work during the exile was an opportunity to set the record straight for posterity. And that they did.
Babylonian intellectuals (mostly, the priest class) presumed that civilization in Mesopotamia before the flood had been handed down by their gods. For that reason, they wanted to connect themselves and their intellectual achievements with knowledge before the flood. It was their way of claiming that their knowledge and skills were divine and, therefore, superior to those of the nations they had conquered. That in turn meant that the gods of those nations were inferior to the gods of Babylon.
The apkallus were the great culture-heroes of preflood knowledge. They were the divine sages of a glorious bygone era. Babylonian kings claimed to be descended from the apkallus and other divine figures from before the flood. The collective claim was that glorious Babylonia was the sole possessor of divine knowledge, and that that empire's rule had the approval of the gods.
The biblical writers and later Jews disagreed. They saw Babylonian knowledge as having demonic origins—in large part because the apkallus themselves were so intertwined with Mesopotamian demonology. The Babylonian elite taught that the divine knowledge of the apkallus had survived the flood through a succeeding postflood generation of apkallus—giant, quasi-divine offspring fathered by the original preflood apkallus.
The biblical writers took what Babylonians thought what was proof of their own divine heritage and told a different story. Yes, there were giants, renowned men, both before and after the flood (Gen. 6:4) But those offspring and their knowledge were not of the true God—they were the result of rebellion against Yahweh by lesser divine beings. Gen. 6:1-4, along with 2 Peter and Jude, portrays Babylon's boast as a horrific transgression and, even worse, the catalyst that spread corruption throughout humankind. Gen. 6:5 is essentially a summary of the effect of the transgression. It gets a little space—it's a restrained account. The later Second Temple Jewish literature goes after it full bore.
1 Enoch 8 goes on to elaborate how certain watchers corrupted humankind by means of forbidden divine knowledge, practices largely drawn from Babylonian sciences, another clear indication that the intellectual context of the story was known to the Second Temple authors. Since the Babylonian apkallus were considered demonic, it is no mystery why Peter and Jude link the events of Gen. 6:1-4 to false teachers (2Pet. 2:1-4). While attacking their aberrant knowledge, Peter and Jude evoke the imagery of Gen. 6. False teachers are “licentious” men who indulge in “defiling lusts” (2 Pet. 2:2, 10; Jude 8). like the divine being of Gen. 6 who “did not keep to their own domain” (Jude 6), defecting from the loyal elohim of Yahweh council, false teachers “despise authority” and “blaspheme majestic beings” whom angels dare not rebuke (2 Pet. 2:9-11; Jude 8-10).
Less obvious is the implication of the incident with respect with the promise seed of Eve. The biblical writers draw attention to Noah's blamelessness (Gen. 6:9). The scripture does not specifically exempt Noah and his family from the sinful cohabitation of Gen. 6:1-4, but since the event was so heinous, it would br absurd to presume otherwise. As concepts like divine sonship begin to appear in the Bible with respect to Yahweh's people Israel (Exo. 4:23), the Israelite king (Psm. 2:7), and, ultimately, the Messiah, the theological messaging became important. Noah is in the line of Christ (Luke 3:36; cf. 3:38). At no point could it be claimed that the ultimate seed of Eve, the messianic deliverer, ws the son of any elohim besides Yahweh.
Genesis 6:1-4 is far from being peripheral in importance. It furthers the theme of conflict between divine rebels (the “seed of the nachash”) and humanity that will impede the progress of Eden's restoration. It is one of two passages in the OT that fundamentally frame the history of Israel as a people and a land. The other one is the subject of the next lesson.